England Their England by A.G. Macdonell

England Their England cover

England Their England by A.G. Macdonell was first published in 1933 and it won the James Tait Black prize that year. My copy is a lovely illustrated Folio Society one. The only other book I’ve read by him was a vintage crime and he did write under various names. My copy is illustrated by Peter Brookes.

The book is set in the early 1920s, Donald Cameron is a young Scot who had been invalided out of the army where he was at the Western Front. When he gets home to Aberdeenshire where his father is a farmer it’s evident that he isn’t much use to his father, and his father tells him to go to England. (Harsh!)

While he was at the front he had met up with a Welshman who had been in publishing. On hearing that Cameron was interested in writing he told Cameron to look him up in London if they ever get out of the war, so that is what he does. The Welshman thinks that a book about the English from a foreigner’s point of view would go down well, and Cameron immerses himself in English society of various sorts as a way of studying them.

His account of a cricket match is apparently the most famous and popular part of this book but for me it was his invitation to a country house Friday to Sunday that was the funniest. Donald was taken in hand by a man who knew how to make an entrance at such a social event. The most important thing was to arrive with masses of luggage which would impress the servants and then receive numerous phone calls from various important persons – all made by Donald’s social advisor of course! It was a hoot.

This is all very much tongue in cheek of course. At the time this book was first published there was a bit of a vogue for such amusing books, by people such as P.G. Wodehouse and Jerome K.Jerome.

I read this one for the Classics Club Challenge, Read Scotland 2016 Challenge and the James Tait Black Challenge – three with one book!

The Factory on the Cliff by A.G. MacDonell

 The Factory on the Cliffs cover

The Factory on the Cliff by A.G. MacDonell was first published in 1928 but it has been reprinted by Fonthill Media. Originally this book was published under MacDonell’s pseudonym Neil Gordon. MacDonell is best known for his book England, Their England. Published in 1933 it’s a satirical comedy on English society and its eccentricities. It won the James Tait Black Award in 1933.

The Factory on the Cliff is written very much in the style of John Buchan, in other words a sort of ‘boys own adventure story’. The story begins with George Templeton on a golfing holiday in Aberdeen, Scotland but when he damages his thumb while using the starting crank on his car it means he can’t golf. He’s the sort of chap who hates walking, unless he happens to be whacking a wee ball along as he goes.

Desperate for some exercise he is forced to take a walk and comes across a group of men acting suspiciously. They’re looking for something but claim that they aren’t. Later George finds a type of Mills bomb (grenade) in the undergrowth and realises that that is what they were looking for.

I think that this sort of adventure tale was very popular when it was first published, especially amongst the many men who would have been involved in the First World War. It involves germ warfare and scientists and Scotland Yard does get involved albeit at a distance. The characters had all been soldiers and in some way it was something that they missed, as apparently men did. There’s only one female character and she is there as a bit of eye candy for the men.

I must admit that I’m happier reading the country house sort of murder mystery but I still enjoyed this book. I also love the cover, very much of its time, but I’m not so enamoured with the size of the book, one of those larger format ones which is just not going to fit on the shelf where I have the rest of my vintage crime books. Annoying.

Archibald Gordon MacDonell was born in India but he regarded himself as a Scotsman so this one counts towards the Read Scotland 2016 Challenge.