The Disorderly Knights by Dorothy Dunnett

The Disorderly Knights cover

The Disorderly Knights by Dorothy Dunnett is the third book in her Lymond series and was first published in 1966.

I had a look at Goodreads to see what other readers thought of this one because although I loved the second half of the book there were parts of the first half that dragged for me. I really wasn’t too keen on the bits that were set in Malta and Tripoli, but by the time the action switched back to Scotland I found myself sitting up in bed – still reading at 2.30 am.

I don’t even think that this book is really perfect for bedtime reading as you have to concentrate on it, but when it got to 2.30 I had sworn to myself that I would put the light out at the end of the chapter and then I noticed that the next chapter sub-heading was Dumbarton, April/May 1552 – which just happens to be the town that I grew up in! I forced myself to give up for the night though, despite dying to know what was going to be happening at Dumbarton.

As it turned out I was slightly disappointed because Dunnett didn’t describe the town’s surroundings at all, which makes me think that she didn’t go there to do any research as there are lots of lovely hills and crags around Dumbarton to describe, and the castle rock is visible for miles around and would have been even more so in those days. Mind you nowadays you could just get on the internet and look at Google earth if you want to describe a location.

Dunnett wound this tale around actual historical events and a few of the people were real too. As ever I really started to dislike Lymond a lot, for most of the book he seemed like an out and out baddie, but I should have known better by now. When he gets back to Scotland he has the job of training a large amount of men who are going to be used to keep the rule of law in the Scottish Border country where the land has been constantly fought over by the Scots and English, in truth those Border families were only ever interested in their own survival, seeing themselves as being on neither the Scottish or English side, and who could blame them for that. Lymond is also thinking of himself as he is being employed by the English to keep the peace in the Border lands, but that’s easier said than done.

Meanwhile Graham Reid Malett/Gabriel who is a ‘high heid yin’ in the Noble Order of Knights Hospitallers is making a good job of putting Lymond in a bad position, making him look like an absolute swine!

4 thoughts on “The Disorderly Knights by Dorothy Dunnett

  1. I spent more nights reading into the wee hours with Lymond than I ever had before or have since! Such a wonderful cast of characters in this book!

    I am more than overdue for a re-reading of the Chronicles.

    • Lisa,
      Me too! I thought I already had a copy of Pawn in Frankincense but I’ve just discovered I don’t. I meant to say also that I live just a few miles from Falkland where a lot of the action takes place, and I’m there every week, it’s all so local to me.

  2. I loved this book, mainly because of the wonderful second half (the Malta chapters weren’t my favourites either). I’m not surprised it kept you up until 2.30!

    • Helen,
      Yes for me too it was definitely a work of two halves, but on the other hand the Malta/Tripoli parts were necessary for the storyline. I’ve just bought the next one online so I’ll be reading it soonish I think.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *