The Lake District Murder by John Bude

The Lake District Murder cover

The Lake District Murder by John Bude was first published in 1935, but I read the British Library Crime Classics reprint.

This book begins well with a murder almost immediately, just the way I like it, but Inspector William Meredith gets completely side-tracked by another mystery for most of the book. Bude seems to have modelled his writing style on that of Freeman Wills Crofts, but he ended up being more convoluted and detailed than FWC and it became very tedious.

He was so concerned with the plot that he made very little of the various characters, most of which are male. I longed for Mrs Meredith to make an appearance, but after a short but spirited spat with her husband the detective, she almost completely disappeared.

The lovely scenery of the Lake District barely gets a mention. John Bude seems to have assumed that his books would be read by men – and men who were just keen on calculations and measurements at that. I was really amused by this part though:

Wick expectorated with a mingled air of disdain and disgust and pulled out a packet of Woodbines. He had now completed the charging of the petrol tank and was leaning back against one of the pumps, watching the Inspector with ill-concealed impatience.

“Now look here, Wick,” said Meredith briskly. “I want to know something. What time did the Nonock lorry leave your garage last night?”

Wick slowly lit his cigarette, considering the point.

Health and Safety would go nuts if you lit up whilst leaning against a fuel pump nowadays!!

I found this book to be quite disappointing, but as usual the cover is a great one and it has been taken from a 1930s railway poster (LNER) advertising Ullswater English Lakeland, by the artist John Littlejohns.


2 thoughts on “The Lake District Murder by John Bude

  1. I do know how you feel about this one. I think that if they’re going to resurrect a mystery or other novel from earlier in the 19th century, they should pick wonderful classics, that have been overlooked and that will still be beloved by people today.
    I’ve been pretty lucky so far with my resurrected books, but how I hate to be disappointed in a less than stellar book. I don’t think any of us have time for that.

    • Judith,
      I’ve read quite a few of these books and there’s quite a high ‘dud’ rate. Possibly this sort of book is aimed at non-communicative men who don’t like getting into a character’s personality. Or maybe that’s me being sexist!

Leave a Reply

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked *